Every manager eventually encounters a challenging employee. It might be someone who resists cooperation, frequently misses work, or consistently stirs up conflict. Managing difficult employees can feel draining, but it’s also an opportunity to reinforce your leadership and strengthen your team.
Common Traits of Difficult Employees Challenging team members may display:
- Lack of cooperation
- Attendance issues
- Poor performance
- Negative attitudes or frequent conflicts
Step 1: Define and Document the Problem Before taking action, clearly identify the behaviors that are creating issues. Then, document every conversation, incident, and effort to support the employee.
Step 2: Communicate Directly and Honestly Don’t skirt around the issue. Set up a private meeting to:
- Share specific concerns
- Ask the employee to share their perspective
- Clarify expectations and performance standards
Step 3: Offer Support Determine if the root cause is skills-related, personal, or something else. If the employee is open to improvement, create a performance plan with achievable goals.
Step 4: Know When to Let Go Not every employee will turn around. If someone refuses to cooperate despite support and documentation, it may be time to part ways. But ensure you’ve followed due process and treated them with fairness and dignity.
Tips for Staying Calm and Professional
- Don’t take things personally
- Stay focused on the behavior, not the person
- Avoid public criticism
- Be consistent in how you handle similar situations
Managing difficult employees is a challenge, but it also gives you a chance to lead with integrity and clarity. With the right balance of empathy and accountability, you can protect your team culture while giving struggling employees a fair chance to succeed.
Need help training your managers? Check out our Enhanced HR service!